An initiative of Gawda, Kunbi, Velip and Dhangar Federation (GAKUVED)
Saturday, March 18, 2023
Architect Elsa's pre-emptive letter to Santa Cruz Panchayat
Friday, March 17, 2023
How Indian Constitution is butchered at Santa Cruz Gram Sabha
February 26, 2023 is a day amongst dark days in Goa with regard to Freedom of Speech and Expression. On this day Santa Cruz Panchayat suppressed the voice of Architech Elsa Fernandes. While speaking at the Gram Sabha sound system was whisked away from her hands. She had submitted nine points for discussion at the Gram Sabha. Constitutional violations at Santa Cruz Gram Sabha has found its way into public domain with media facilitation.
Architect Elsa Fernandes has been a crusader for Justice through out her life and had to fight her way through overcoming number of hurdles. There were several attempts to stop her passion for Justice but she has always triumphed. Often it was solitary journey but her gutsy endeavors earned her daring reputation.
Her current engagement in Santa Cruz regarding Gram Sabha Development Plan and defence of Khazan lands from encroachments has earned her fresh opponents from the ruling group at Santa Cruz Panchayat. Various tactics are being deployed to intimidating her. Goa at this stage cannot afford to let her opponent prevail over her into silence. For that would be a tragedy unimaginable.
There are clues that suggest that access to her house in Santa Cruz might be arbitrary blocked on Sunday or Holiday putting her family of six members under stress. At this moment we pledge support to Architect Elsa Fernandes for she has contributed hugely to Goa already with her indomitable voice.
It is time that Goa is put on alert for all that she is going through just because she opted to stand in the side of Truth and Justice. For this she commands respects from people of Goa. Santa Cruz MLA Rudolf Fernades must lead at this moments and defend Architech Elsa Fernandes or claims of being Goa Protector is all hot air.
Thursday, March 16, 2023
Elsa Fernandes complaint against Santa Cruz Panchayat officials
From:
Elsa Fernandes,
Segundo Bairo, Santa Cruz, Goa
Date: 27/02/2023
To,
The Block Development Officer, Tiswadi Block, Panaji, Goa
2 The
Director,
Directorate
of Panchayat, Panaji, Goa
Sub: Complaint against the Sarpanch Mrs. Jenifer De
Oliveira and Deputy Sarpanch Mr. Inacio Domnic Pereira of Santa Cruz Village
Panchayat for connivance and obstruction of my rights in the Gram Sabha
meeting.
Sir,
I submit as under;
1. On Sunday 26/2/2023 was
the ordinary Gram Sabha of Santa Cruz village.
2. I am a villager of Santa
Cruz, residing at Segundo Bairo ward, Santa Cruz, Goa.
3. I had submitted a request
on 22/02/2023 well in advance for consideration of discussion at the said Gram
Sabha.
4. I presume the BDO, Tiswadi
was present at the Gram Sabha as an observer.
5. The Gram Sabha was also
video recorded hence kindly verify the developments stated below.
6. As the Secretary finished
reading the minutes and I raised a issue for clarification in the minutes, I
was stopped by the Deputy Sarpanch saying that he is not allowing me to talk on
it, because my name is not part of those minutes so I have no right to discuss
that content. So, I was dis-allowed.
7. The Sarpanch, agreed with
him and my right to speak on those minutes was denied to me, while other
members continued to speak and I realised that I am being discriminated and
denied my rights to speak in the Gram Sabha.
8. Further, I was disturbed
with this unbecoming attitude towards me and I could not participate very
generously as the Deputy sarpanch was mocking at me every time I asked
something to the Sarpanch and the Sarpanch did nothing to correct the
disrespect being shown to me continuously from her presiding table.
9. Finally, my request for
discussion considerations were taken up. I had 9 questions and Q.No.1 to 4 only
were taken up and from Q.No.5 to 9 were not allowed.
10.
The Sarpanch informed me that the Panchayat body has refused
permission to allow my questions in Gram Sabha so she is not allowing them.
11.
I inquired why then I was not told in the beginning and why 4
questions were allowed and in fact even the Deputy Sarpanch was raising my last
Q.No.9 before hand after Q.No.2 was going on.
12.
No explanation was given to me and I was disallowed the rest
of my Q.no.5 to Q.No.9, which are all pertinent questions to the Gram Sabha as
I suspect manipulation of the Gram Sabha and the Funds of the Panchayat by the
all those who are heading the Panchayat.
13.
During the discussions on my Q.No.2 and 3 the Sarpanch allowed
a lot of commotion, physically blocking me from talking, snatching away my
mike, shouting, making personal remarks, etc. All this appears clearly like a
pre-plan as the husband of the Sarpanch, Mr. Tome De Oliveira, the
Sister-in-law of the Sarpanch Mrs. Gema, the daughter of the Sarpanch Miss
Shiny De Oliveira who is also the Zilla Panch of Santa Cruz, the wife of the
Deputy Sarpanch, Mrs Andrea, the ex-panch from Alto-Santa Cruz and another lady
who claimed to be VDC member were all planted to sabotage my questions by
attempting all the above behaviour. They also raised cross questions addressing
me directly with irresponsible and unprofessional comments. The Sarpanch Mrs.
Jenifer and the Deputy Sarpanch Mr. Inacio appeared to have personal pre-judice
against me which they allowed to rule over the laws of the Gram Sabha and my
right to speak and seek discussion on planning and funds of my village Santa
Cruz. The Gram Sabha was captured by goonda family Raj elements and I fear for
my health, well being and safety and that of my family.
I pray for immediate inquiry into
this incident related to attack and violations of my rights in the Gram Sabha
and action to be taken against it.
Awaiting your response at the
earliest else I will be forced to seek legal remedy if left with no option as I
fear grave manipulations of Gram Sabha, GPDP and finances.
Thanking you.
Sd/-
Elsa Fernandes
Fresh intimidating tactics against noted Environmental Architect Elsa Fernandes
Tome Oliveira husband of sarpanch Jennifer had come today afternoon around 12.00 noon near my house in Segundo Bairo to do recce of my house and have even spoken to one of my neighbours to coerce intimidating tactics on me.
I am informing all by this message just incase there is any criminal activity against me or my family or my property
Also in my college he and the dy sarpanch has mastermind in the name of Krishna Pandit and filed RTI on my name asking all my personal details against whom I have also filed a police complaint
All this is being done as revenge against me because I have asked questions in the gram sabha about the village
Elsa Fernandes
Santa Cruz,
Goa
Tuesday, March 14, 2023
Bold letter that triggered irate of Santa Cruz Village Panchayat
From:
Elsa Fernandes,
Segundo Bairo, Santa Cruz, Goa
Date: 22/02/2023
To,
The Sarpanch/Secretary,
Village Panchayat of Santa Cruz, Goa
Sub: Points to be discussed in the ordinary Gram Sabha Scheduled on 26/02/2023
Madam,
Kindly include the following for the ducussion in the Scheduled Ordinary Gram Sabha of Santa Cruz VP on 26/02/2023;
1. As per the Goa Panchayats (Gram Sabha Meetings) (First Amendment) Rules, 2016, under Rule 18, the proceedings of every meeting of the Gram Sabha shall be recorded in a video and shall form part of records of Gram Sabha. I am interested in obtaining this record after each Gram Sabha meeting, hence please consider this as a reminder of the above mandate issued by the Government of Goa. Also, this is a request that this provision in Rule 18 should be clearly read out to the Gram Sabha on 26/02/2023.
2. As per the theme which needs to be adopted by our village Panchayatfor the localization of SDG (LSDG), Kindly give the updated status about it and the plan of action decided.
3. Kindly give the names of all present VDC members who have taken training from GIPARD in preparation of Gram Panchayat Development Plan.
4. Mention the details of two projects with highest cost which have already been paid from the finance commision funds (14th or 15th). Provide details as name of project, amount of cost paid, date of payment made, signatories to the payment, name of the party to whom the payment was made, VDC minutes showing approval of the said projects, Gram Sabha minutes showing approval of the same and printout details of the said project uploaded online. Provide GPDP updated Asset Register on the Gram Sabha day for verification.
5. How many projects under Part-I and Part-II of GPDP are still pending from 14th finance funds period.
6. How many projects in Part-I and Part-II have been uploaded online after the Gram Sabha approval of the current GPDP. Give the break-up number ward wise of the same along with the total cost.
7. Give the names of all the committes constituted as mandated under various Act, Notifications, Circulars, etc of the Govt of India or Govt of Goa. Has each committee members so selected been given order to this effect to inform them officially?
8. Give the dates of Garbage Management Committee meetings held from 2021 till date.
9. Give the status of the Panchayat Ghar project till date with all important details. The plot where the Panchayat Ghar is proposed is within Khazan area and Flood hazard line of the CZMP 2011, what approvals have been undertaken so far to consider these eco-sensitive issues which can potentially damage the environment of the village. What is the further plan of action on this environmental damage.
Kindly record the above in the Gram Sabha discussion so it can be requested as certified copies for my further process. Hoping all above will bring transparency in the working of the Village Panchayat and the Gram Sabha gets update of all the above details.
Thanking you.
Yours faithfully,
Sd/-
Elsa Fernandes
Ripples of Santa Cruz Gram Sabha
On February 26, 2023 Santa Cruz Gram Sabha meeting took place at Goa. One of the Gram Sabha members Architect Elsa Fernandes was abruptly stopped from speaking at the Gram Sabha constituting violation of her Fundamental Right of Freedom and Expression guaranteed under the Article 19 of the Constitution of India.
The following video is online giving some glimpses into the controversy.
https://fb.watch/jc92dyAzu6/?mibextid=1YhcI9R
There are allegations and counter allegations from various quarters chiefly divided into two camps: Architect Elsa Fernandes versus the Panchayat of Santa Cruz in Goa. The video is a great incentive to probe into what Goa is currently in its political dimensions.
Sunday, March 12, 2023
Massive illegal trawling at Zuari river
It has been detected between 10.00 pm to 10.40 pm today March 12, 2023 that around 10 trawlers are carrying on illegal fishing in Zuari river within one kilometers of Odxel-Dona Paula Jetty shoreline with lights off.
Complaints are lodged at Goa Fisheries Control room but response indicate that staff is absent to put Fisheries patrol boat in waters. Patrol boats is currently tied up in Panjim with Bosun absent. Illegal fishing in the dark of the night therefore is beyond control leading to collapse of law and order in Zuari with massive loot.
Fisheries Minister Nilkhant Halarnkar has to get going in cracking down on Fisheries department- Trawler nexus connected with illegal fishing.